Understanding the Difference Between Primary and Secondary Osteoporosis

Osteoporosis / March 14, 2016

Primary Vs. Secondary – The Types of Osteoporosis

Types of Osteoporosis | Primary Osteoporosis | Causes of Secondary Osteoporosis | Primary and Secondary Osteoporosis treatment Options 

There are four types of osteoporosis: primary osteoporosis, secondary osteoporosis, osteogenesis imperfecta, and idiopathic juvenile osteoporosis.

From there, the two main types of osteoporosis common in adults are: primary and secondary osteoporosis.

      • Primary osteoporosis is known as either being age-related osteoporosis, or an unknown cause.(1)  This is the most common form of osteoporosis.  Why?  The biggest factor is age.  As you know, once you reach peak bone mass you begin to lose 1% of your total bone density, annually.  This is coupled with the fact that as you also get older, your ability to build bone also decreases.  Bone loss increases, bone building decreases.  A dangerous cocktail. There are two types of primary osteoporosis: type 1 and type 2.

Type 1: Also known as postmenopausal osteoporosis. This generally develops in women after menopause due to decreases in estrogen production. But can also be from testosterone deficiency. This type is more common in women than men and typically during the ages of 50-70 years old.

Type 2: Also known as senile osteoporosis. This typically develops after the age of 70 in older men and women, although it’s more common in women. It is associated with decreased bone formation and a decrease in vitamin D production.

      • Secondary osteoporosis on the other hand is when the loss of bone is caused by certain lifestyle behaviors, diseases or medications.  Unfortunately, there is a long list of medical conditions or diseases that lead to low bone mass. They range from genetic conditions such as diabetes, cystic fibrosis to blood disorders such as anemia. If you have a chronic condition and have been taking medication for some time, it’s even more crucial to focus on diet and exercise. You may be surprised to learn that some of the most common medications contribute to bone loss. These include contraceptives, aromatase inhibitors, anticonvulsants, thyroid medications and blood coagulants to name a few. For the complete list, click here.

Primary Osteoporosis

 

      • Osteogenesis imperfecta is an extremely rare form of osteoporosis and is present at birth. With osteogenesis imperfecta, bones break easily and without reason and is caused by several genes that don’t function properly.
      • Idiopathic juvenile osteoporosis is usually seen as a secondary feature from either a chronic diseases of from treatment (medications for a chronic condition). For a full list of diseases that can lead to osteoporosis in children, go here.

Is There Really Such a Thing as Primary Osteoporosis?

We’ve defined the technical term for primary osteoporosis above.  But is this term still relevant?  Is there really such a thing as ‘primary’ osteoporosis?

Let me explain…

Authorities and experts state that there is no direct or singular cause for primary osteoporosis.(2)  Yes, primary osteoporosis is vaguely attributed to age-related bone loss, but we now know that it’s caused by concrete factors that affect the aging population.

These include:

        • Vitamin D Deficiency: Recent research shows a high prevalence of vitamin D deficiency afflicting over half of certain elderly populations! This is also associated with a higher risk of fracture. (3) 
        • Reduced Muscle Mass:  Older adults tend to lose lean tissue more rapidly than their younger counterparts during prolonged periods of physical inactivity.(4) As with decreased bone density as you age, this also happens with muscle mass.
        • Lack of bone building nutrients:  Poor nutrition or malnutrition occurs in 15 to 20% of the elderly population.(5)  Making sure you are getting adequate amounts of the vitamins and minerals needed for bone health is crucial.

Starting to make sense?

You see, it’s important to uncover the underlying cause of your osteoporosis.

Take Lara Pizzorno, author of “Your Bones” for instance. She discovered she had osteopenia in her early 40s! Instead of of accepting that it may be due to certain risk factors such as family history, gender and race… she decided to look for any additional underlying causes to explain her bone loss.

And she did.  She found out that she has a vitamin D receptor that doesn’t function properly, making it difficult for her to absorb vitamin D. She also found out that she doesn’t activate certain B vitamins.  So while these inabilities contribute to bone loss, she is now informed. With this knowledge, Lara was able to treat the cause, instead of suppressing her symptoms . Watch her full story.

So if you are suffering from bone loss, we recommend looking deeper.  You may be surprised at what you find.

Causes Associated with Secondary Osteoporosis

As we discussed, secondary osteoporosis is caused by certain lifestyle factors, diseases or nutritional deficiencies.

The following tables provide insight into secondary causes:

Nutrition:

Nutrition Anti-Nutrients Common Diet Choices/Habits
Food restriction Cola type sodas High sugar intake
Lack of bone building nutrients Excess salt intake Processed and refined foods
Imbalance of bone building nutrients Excess alcohol consumption High starch intake
Excess Phosphorous Excess caffeine intake Inadequate intake of fruits and vegetables
Excess vitamin A Skipping meals

Lifestyle Factors:

Physical Activity Other
Inadequate physical activity Smoking
Muscle deterioration Stress (increases levels of cortisol)
Immobilization (bed rest) Mood (fear, unhappiness or worry)
Surgeries (bariatric, hysterectomy, gastrointestinal etc.)
Use of sunscreen
Medications

Medical Conditions:

Digestive Disorders Rheumatological/ Autoimmune Diseases Connective tissue/Genetic disorders Endocrine or Metabolic Causes Neurological Diseases
Celiac Disease Rheumatoid Arthritis Cystic fibrosis Hyperparathyroidism Spinal cord injury
Gastric Bypass Multiple Sclerosis Glycogen storage diseases Hyperthyroidism Parkinson’s disease
Inflammatory Bowel Disease Lupus Hypophosphatasia Adrenal disorders, including:

Adrenal insufficiency

Cushing’s syndrome

Hyperadrenocorticism

Epilepsy

Medications:

The following are the medicine classes which are currently known to play a role in or cause osteoporosis:

Drug Class Commonly Prescribed For –

          • NSAIDS – Non-steroidal Anti-inflammatory Drugs pain relief, especially arthritic pain
          • Corticosteroids – a wide variety of conditions
          • Contraceptives – the pill, plus injectable
          • Aromatase Inhibitors – cancer treatment
          • Gonadotrophin releasing agonists – endometriosis, breast cancer, prostate
          • Anticonvulsants – epilepsy, bipolar, neuropathic pain
          • Benzodiazepines – depression, schizophrenia, insomnia
          • Antidepressants – depression, anxiety
          • Insulin sensitizing agents –  type 2 diabetes
          • Opioid Pain Medications – severe pain management
          • Calcineurin inhibitors – immune system suppression
          • Antacids/Proton Pump Inhibitors – indigestion, heart burn
          • Loop diuretics  – blood pressure, liver cirrhosis
          • Blood coagulants  – prevent excessive blood clotting
          • Thyroid Medications – hypothyroidism

Please consult your doctor before stopping or altering the dosage of any medication. Only your doctor and you can decide the risks versus benefits of a medicine.

Primary & Secondary Osteoporosis Treatment

Osteoporosis treatments include a multifaceted approach focusing on diet, lifestyle habits, exercise and for some, medications. AlgaeCal Plus

But the good news is, there are natural treatment options if this is what you choose.

One in particular, has been backed by science and published in prominent and peer-reviewed journals such as PubMed, The Nutrition Journal and now a 7-year follow up study in the Journal of the American College of Nutrition. It’s the only bone-building supplement to be backed by this type of research.

It’s called AlgaeCal. And it’s been supported to increase bone density…even in 80 year old women! Naturally. And without side effects. For more information on this multi-mineral bone supplement, go here.


Sources:
  1. algaecal.com/expert-insights/osteoporosis-in-men/
  2. betterbones.com/osteoporosis/secondaryosteoporosis.aspx
  3. Thomas MK et al, Hypovitaminosis D in medical inpatients. N Eng J Med 1998;338:777-783
  4. English, Kirk L., and Douglas Paddon-Jones. “Protecting Muscle Mass and Function in Older Adults during Bed Rest.” Current Opinion in Clinical Nutrition and Metabolic Care 13.1 (2010): 34–39. PMC. Web. 25 Feb. 2016.
  5. sparkpeople.com/resource/nutrition_articles.asp?id=869
Monica

8 thoughts on “Understanding the Difference Between Primary and Secondary Osteoporosis

Israel Naftali

I’m only 53 years old men, and my T-score is -3.3 in lumbar part of vertebrae. I’m working physically as a gardener for 19 years in Israel. There is enough sun and movement during my work day. All hormonal tests are normal, but urine Calcium leakage is very high – 443/24 hours. And I was diagnosed two 3-4 mm kidney stones in left kidney. In my vertebrae I have a birth defect – two additional semi-vertebrae in lumbar and thoracic parts.
Are these AlgaeCal additives suitable for me? How it works with hypercalciuria? Or I need to pass any additional tests?
Your reply will be highly appreciated.
Thank you in advance!

Monica

Hello,

First, I would recommend finding out what is causing your hypercalciuria. Common causes are hyperparathyroidism, excessive vitamin D intake, sarcoidosis etc. Once you know the cause, then you can treat it accordingly.

AlgaeCal Plus is very different from traditional (rock-based) calcium supplements and is the only calcium proven to increase bone density. To know if it is suitable for you and your condition, please consult with your physician as they will know your entire health history and be able to asess properly. You can also print out and take with you the following sheet, which helps explain AlgaeCal to your doctor: https://cdn.algaecal.com/wp-content/uploads/Take-it-to-your-doctor.pdf

– Monica from AlgaeCal

Fred Zariczny

Hi Monica,
I am a 62 yr. old man and I have severe osteoporosis in my thoracic spine area, and ostopenia in my hip. I have broken t7, t8, t9 three times and also broke t5 &t6 once. I have been taking AlgaeCal as well as lots of vit. D3, K2, etc.

I also quit sugar – as I previously drank lots of soda and energy drinks. I’m trying to get as much exercise as I can and prayer.

We also use natural liquid vitamins now Nutrience by the Caltons, and I take Moringa Olifera by Zija (Supermix) – which seems to really help – instead of pain pills.

So I’m ta king th natural route as much as possible. I do drink 2 cups of coffee a day and use stevia.

I have a hard time taking the Strontium as you’re supposed to wait two hours after any calcium. So I don’t get that much. But I’M pretty faithful with the Algaecal.

We’re reading Micronutrients by the Catonsville and eating organic and we’re gluten free too.

Anyway hope I’m… on the right track to getting better.

Thanks,
Fred

Monica

Hi Fred,

Thank you so much for sharing. It does sound like you are on the right track to reclaiming your bone health (and overall health)!

Don’t worry too much about the 2 cups of coffee, Lara Pizzorno has a great video on why here: https://www.algaecal.com/expert-insights/video-lara-pizzorno-coffee-safe-bones/

As for Strontium, one way to take it more regularly is to take it at night before bed. Just put it by your sink as a reminder after brushing your teeth 🙂

Hope that helps!

– Monica from AlgaeCal

Elaine Waisglass

1. The recommended dose on the AlgaeCal bottle label is two caps morning and night. Would it be helpful to take more for the purpose of correcting bone loss? If not, what would be the reason? Is there an upper limit to the amount that should be taken?

Monica

Hi Elaine,

We don’t usually recommend more than 4 capsules of AlgaeCal Plus daily unless you practice a vegan diet. The reason is that most people get about 500mg of calcium from their diet and 4 capsules of AlgaeCal Plus provides you with 720mg of calcium, so together, you’re getting around the recommended daily 1,200 mg of calcium. If your diet lacks calcium, we would recommend a maximum of 5 capsules daily. This is because your body can only absorb so many minerals in one day so taking more than 5 capsules (900mg) will be wasteful as the unabsorbed calcium will be excreted through your urine.

Further, our studies show that 4 capsules of AlgaeCal Plus being effective. You can view those studies here: https://www.algaecal.com/research/

I hope this clears up you concerns.

– Monica from AlgaeCal

E Duncan

I have taken Armour Thyroid, for the past few years, as finally a doctor tested the t-3 and t-4 levels that for many years went unrecognized as the issue….leaving me dragging and pushing to function through much of my adult life.

However, I have discovered I have osteoporosis just a few years ago ( early 50’s), most likely from teenage years of starving and not giving myself proper nutrition fur many years.

Luckily I discovered AlgaeCal after much research, and take it faithfully, along with strontium.

I need to continue to take the thyroid medication, though; will the AlgaeCal and strontium be able to help me overcome my past history and current thyroid use?

Thank you.

Monica

Hi E Duncan,

AlgaeCal Plus and Strontium Boost have been proven to increase bone density – but we cannot guarantee this if you are on thyroid medication. This is because your medication and your condition could actually be causing your bone loss. BUT we have had customers taking AlgaeCal Plus and Strontium Boost and thyroid medication who have seen results. You can see those here: https://www.algaecal.com/expert-insights/tag/success-stories/ If you would to take AlgaeCal Plus and Strontium Boost, remember not to take the AlgaeCal Plus at the same time as your thyroid medication. This is to avoid any interaction.

– Monica from AlgaeCal

Add your voice to this discussion...

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

crave your fish oil
Guaranteed to increase your bone density in 180 days!

DISCOVER HOW TO INCREASE YOUR BONE DENSITY NATURALLY…

open quote

I'll show you how!

close quote

Dean Neuls

AlgaeCal CEO & CO-Founder

Subscribe today to receive:
  • Free expert tips on improving bone density
  • Delicious bone-healthy recipes
  • The latest breakthroughs in bone health science

Your personal information is 100% Confidential. Privacy Policy

FREE EBOOK:

Recipes for Stronger Bones

Recipes for Stronger Bones

Now you can build strong bones one healthy, delicious meal at a time!

Crave your fish oil!